Roleplayer & Character: Pippin with Danika
Cohesiveness: 3
Comments: - “Though to herself” - should be thought
-“He at least would not tower over her like the brute Hound, even still he looked to be much bulker than your own light draft frame” - bulker should be bulkier. In addition this sentence is just a bit off. It would have sounded better if it were more like “While he would at least not tower over her like the brute hound, he still looked to be much bulkier than her own light draft frame.”
- “Again she figured her best bet was to avoid closing with him as best as she could” - maybe closing the distance between them? Closing in on him?
- “As the fancy moves she tired” - should be tried
- “She let her caramel eyes fall on that sight for a moment for looking back at the stallion” - should be before, not for.
- “So she didn’t loss footing” - should be lose footing.
- “So instead Dankia closed in closer” - Dankia should be Danika
- “Feeling hooves slide on the snow covered ground as she turned to face the stallion once more.” This sentence could be better. It should be “She felt her hooves slide as she turned to face”.
- “She latched out with front hooves” should be lashed out.
- “Desperate to get away from the river, even if that meant closing back closer with her opponent when she caught sight of the stallion in question.” This sentence sort of changes directions half way through. It’s two different ideas here that could have been written in a better way. For example, “She was desperate to get away from the river, even if that meant putting herself closer with her opponent. Moving away from the water, she then caught sight of the stallion in question….” etc etc
- The words “bulk” were used a few times close together in your third post, would have liked to see a larger variety of vocabulary.
- “She had felt like her slid had been forever” slid should be slide.
- “But in reality it had only lasted a minuet” minuet should be minute.
- “So hurt all over from the fall and had to keep blinking to keep her left eye clear” - Either should be “she hurt all over, and she had to keep blinking”.
- He at least would not tower over her like the brute Hound, even still he looked to be much bulker than her own light draft frame. -- Bulker should be bulkier
- Again she figured her best bet was to avoid closing with him as best she could. -- Sentence reads awkwardly, unable to determine what it's supposed to mean
- She knew from mistakes in her last match that she could not move with as much agility as the fancy moves she tired had caused great flare ups of pain. -- Tired should be tried
- She though to herself and then a sound rang out signaling the start of the match. -- Though should be thought
- She then spun away, careful not to move too quickly so she didn't loss footing as she darted back out of his range. -- Loss should be lose
- There was no high winds or battling pairs this time to create unknowns and distractions. - Was should be were
- Panic set it and before she could formulate a plan his lager bulk was crashing into her. -- Lager should be larger
- She felt her breath whoosh out of her in gasp. -- Gasp should be a gasp
- Each small impact insignificant on there own but added up together left her feeling like a million tiny daggers danced across her body. -- There should be their
- She had felt like her slid had been forever, an endless track of time -- Slid should be slide
- But in reality it had only lasted a minuet, probably less, and had only sent her a few feet away from the stallion. -- Minuet should be minute
- She felt the last her strength ebb away as she pushed herself to her limit and than past it. -- Should be "of her strength" and also then not than
- Consistent spelling/grammar issues made posts difficult to read
Realism: 9.5
Comments:- Took note of the environment around her and how it effected her, particularly in the post where she nearly ends up in the river
- Attacks felt realistic.
- I like her constantly addressing the environment.
- Where I took off a point here is addressing her injuries, and how much they have affected her. In her first battle, she went down to 85% health. In her second battle, she received a deep injury on her wither from a bite from Hound, she was slightly battered from hitting the ground, AND she received another bite near her stifle. I think it's a little unrealistic that, on top of the pain she was feeling from her first battle, that that only did 5% damage. I would have preferred to see her start at a lower health percentage, considering.
Movement: 9
Comments:- After Aftershock’s first attack, it said that Danika felt his kick but then she was out of his range, but it doesn’t describe how she got out of his range. I would have liked to see a better description here.
- Otherwise, Danika's attacks, as well as how she moved after the attacks, felt well thought out.
- Movements felt like they didn't make the most sense when she got up and rushed Aftershock after her near fall into the river
Completion of Form: 10
Comments:- Completed correctly (other than what I mentioned above for more consideration of health percentage)
- Completed
TOTAL: 31.5
Roleplayer & Character: TrinitySilph with Aftershock
Cohesiveness: 10
Comments:- I greatly appreciate your writing ability, and how you're able to describe things, but while keeping it short and concise. Really nice read.
- "Breath came raggedly" I feel like should have been breaths, or each breath.
- Posts flowed nicely and read well
Realism: 10
Comments:- Took note of opponents current injuries
- Attacks felt realistic.
- Took into account the environment in each post.
Movement: 10
Comments:- Attacks felt reasonable.
- Movements made more sense compared to opponent
Completion of the Form: 10
Comments:- Completed correctly.
TOTAL: 40
The winner of this round is TrinitySilph & Aftershock!Please prepare yourself for the fourth round of battling.